• About Us / Contact
  • Responsible Gambling
This site contains commercial content
SportsHandle
  • US Sports Betting
    • Arizona
    • Arkansas
    • Colorado
    • Connecticut
    • Delaware
    • Illinois
    • Indiana
    • Iowa
    • Kansas
    • Louisiana
    • Maine
    • Maryland
    • Massachusetts
    • Michigan
    • Mississippi
    • New Jersey
    • New Mexico
    • New York
    • Ohio
    • Oregon
    • Pennsylvania
    • Tennessee
    • Virginia
    • West Virginia
    • Wyoming
  • Pending States
    • California
    • Florida
    • Georgia
    • Missouri
    • North Carolina
  • Canada
    • Ontario
    • British Columbia
    • Alberta
  • Sportsbook Apps
    • FanDuel
    • BetMGM
    • Caesars
    • PointsBet
    • BetRivers
  • Tools
    • Sportsbook Bonuses Explained
    • Sports Betting Revenue Tracker
    • Sports Betting Podcasts
    • Partnership Tracker
    • Expected Value
    • Sports Scores And Odds Apps
    • Sports Betting Twitter
    • Guide To ‘Risk-Free’ Bets
  • News
No Result
View All Result
SportsHandle
  • US Sports Betting
    • Arizona
    • Arkansas
    • Colorado
    • Connecticut
    • Delaware
    • Illinois
    • Indiana
    • Iowa
    • Kansas
    • Louisiana
    • Maine
    • Maryland
    • Massachusetts
    • Michigan
    • Mississippi
    • New Jersey
    • New Mexico
    • New York
    • Ohio
    • Oregon
    • Pennsylvania
    • Tennessee
    • Virginia
    • West Virginia
    • Wyoming
  • Pending States
    • California
    • Florida
    • Georgia
    • Missouri
    • North Carolina
  • Canada
    • Ontario
    • British Columbia
    • Alberta
  • Sportsbook Apps
    • FanDuel
    • BetMGM
    • Caesars
    • PointsBet
    • BetRivers
  • Tools
    • Sportsbook Bonuses Explained
    • Sports Betting Revenue Tracker
    • Sports Betting Podcasts
    • Partnership Tracker
    • Expected Value
    • Sports Scores And Odds Apps
    • Sports Betting Twitter
    • Guide To ‘Risk-Free’ Bets
  • News
No Result
View All Result
SportsHandle
No Result
View All Result

Wagering In Florida In 2023? Judges Seem Split After Oral Arguments

Attorney says federal law defines location of bet as where it's placed AND accepted, making tribal pact illegal

Jill R. Dorson by Jill R. Dorson
December 14, 2022
in Legal
facade-us-courthouse-washington-dc

Shutterstock

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Indian Gaming Regulatory Act is generally interpreted as governing gaming on tribal lands and gives tribes across the U.S. the right to offer it. In addition, Hamish Hume, an attorney for a pair of Florida parimutuels, said U.S. law defines the location of gambling as where the bet is placed and accepted.

Yet the Seminole Tribe’s 2021 compact with the state of Florida defines wagering as having happened on tribal lands no matter the location of the bettor within the state. That, according to Hume, the attorney for West Flagler and Associates, is at the heart of what makes the compact illegal and is wrong with the decision by the U.S. Department of the Interior (DOI) to deem it approved.

Hume made that argument Wednesday morning before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the the District of Columbia. The case in question, West Flagler Associates vs. Secretary Deb Haaland of the U.S. Department of the Interior, could determine the future of legal sports betting in Florida. Should Hume’s argument hold up and the appeals court uphold a lower-court decision, it’s likely the DOI would appeal.

On the flip side, Rachel Heron, on behalf of the DOI, argued that Haaland had no grounds to reject the compact last year because “it does not violate federal law.” In addition, a lawyer for the state of Florida had a chance to argue for “severability,” meaning the compact could be approved with the gambling sections removed; a lawyer for the Seminole Tribe argued that it deserves the opportunity to intervene in the case; and a lawyer for Monterra AF, which has a bigger interest in casino gaming than sports betting, argued that state constitutional issues go beyond the bounds of what the DOI can consider.

Wednesday’s hearing was the latest step in a Florida betting saga that started in May 2021, when the state legislature approved a compact that at least some in Tallahassee believed would be open to court challenges. The compact gives the Florida Seminoles a monopoly on sports betting and would allow for statewide mobile sports betting, as long as all bets flow through servers on Seminole lands. At issue is the idea that the compact violates IGRA, which governs only gambling that happens on tribal lands.

The Florida Legislature approved a new compact with the Seminole Tribe that will bring sports betting to Florida and $2.5 billion to the state treasury over the next five years. https://t.co/6sB5uENwrJ

— Florida Today (@Florida_Today) May 19, 2021

Pathway to appeals court

Once the legislature approved the compact, it was then sent to the DOI for approval. But rather than sign off on it, Haaland instead chose to let the required 45 days pass and let the compact become “deemed approved.”

From there, lawsuits were filed. And in the middle of this case, when it was before the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, the Seminoles launched their Hard Rock Digital app and betting was available in Florida for 34 days before two courts demanded that the Seminoles take the platform down.

Last November, District Court Judge Dabney Friedrich ruled that the compact was illegal and the DOI appealed the decision. The latest iteration of the case has been with the appeals court for more than a year. Wednesday’s arguments were both sides’ opportunity to sway the three-judge panel, but the line of questioning indicated that there is not a consensus on the bench.

Historic day in Florida, Hard Rock Sports betting through the Seminole Tribe went live today on the app anywhere in the state. @MitchMossRadio @paulyhoward pic.twitter.com/iMfJDjdxX8

— Tyler Brumfield (@TylerBrumfiel11) November 1, 2021

Oral arguments opened with Heron arguing on behalf of the DOI, saying that state law is not a reason to reject a compact. But the judges quickly turned Heron’s time into a discussion about whether or not the DOI is adequately representing the Seminole Tribe and the relevance of the post-decision letter supporting its actions from the DOI. The bulk of the questions came from Judge Robert Wilkins, which could indicate that he is leaning toward reversing the district court decision.

Barry Richards, on behalf of the Seminoles, said the tribe would be “pleased” with a reversal and went on to say that the “district court refused to hear from the tribe before making a judgment to destroy the tribe’s most valuable asset.” Meanwhile, Henry Whitaker, on behalf of the state, addressed what the compact authorizes and what is allowed under IGRA.

Judge suggests DOI acted outside its bounds

Hume, who represents the parimutuels that brought the lawsuit, may have had the strongest voice in the courtroom, effectively keeping his arguments on point and hammering home the idea that IGRA only governs gaming on Indian lands.

“IGRA has only one approval provision,” Hume said. “The secretary may approve compacts that allow for [gambling], but there is not a capital A ‘authorize’ on Indian lands and then a ‘wink-wink nudge’ that it’s also legal off Indian lands. The express part of this [compact] is that this makes betting legal off Indian lands.”

Hume got enough questions from Judge Karen Henderson around “ultra vires” action — which is defined as “beyond the power of” — to potentially indicate that she may be leaning toward upholding the lower-court decision that the compact is illegal and that the DOI went beyond its limitations in approving it.

Judge J. Michelle Childs, who was the only one not to tip her hand, could end up being the deciding vote.

Oral arguments lasted just over an hour. A decision by the court is likely weeks, if not months, away.

ShareTweetShare
Jill R. Dorson

Jill R. Dorson

Jill has covered everything from steeplechase to the NFL and then some during a more than 30-year career in sports journalism. The highlight of her career was covering Oakland Raiders during the Charles Woodson/Jon Gruden era, including the infamous “Snow Bowl” and the Raiders’ 2003 trip to Super Bowl XXXVII. Her specialty these days is covering sports betting legislation across the country. You can reach Jill at jill@bettercollective.com

Related Posts

Bob Self/Florida Times-Union/USA TODAY
Sports

Florida’s NFL Teams Make Rare Joint Playoff Appearance, All As Underdogs

January 11, 2023
rendering-draftkings-sportsbook-scottsdale-patio
Analysis

Are Arizona Tribes Being Left Behind As Sports Wagering Grows?

December 7, 2022
Load More

Top Stories

patrick mahomes

Mahomes’ Ankle Speculation Twists Line Movement In Chiefs-Bengals Rematch

January 27, 2023
fanatics-grand-opening

Fanatics Sportsbook At FedEx Field Offers Unique Retail Option In Maryland

January 23, 2023
Shutterstock

Missouri Legislators Lament Exodus Of Bettors To Neighboring States

January 27, 2023
rob gronkowski adam vinatieri

Rob Gronkowski Goes Training Montage Route In Latest FanDuel Spot

January 17, 2023

State Sports Betting Guides

Ohio (U.S. state) flag waving against clear blue sky, close up, isolated with clipping path mask alpha channel transparency, perfect for film, news, composition

Ohio Sports Betting – Where To Play, Bonus Offers And Promo Codes

by Brian Pempus
January 25, 2023

Downtown Detroit at twilight (Shutterstock)

Michigan Sports Betting – Where To Play, Online Sportsbooks, And FAQ

by Brett Smiley
January 27, 2023

VA captial

Virginia Sports Betting – Where To Play, Online Sportsbooks And Bonus Offers

by Brett Smiley
January 17, 2023

nj flag

New Jersey Sports Betting — Where To Play, Online Sportsbooks, And FAQ

by Brett Smiley
October 20, 2022

pa online sportsbooks

Pennsylvania Sports Betting – Where To Play, Online Sportsbooks And Bonuses

by Brett Smiley
October 6, 2022

Canada Sports Betting Guides

Canada Sports Betting – Best Sportsbook Apps & Bonus Offers

British Columbia Sports Betting – Legal Update, Available Sportsbooks, and FAQ

Ontario Sports Betting – Legal Status And Where To Play

gambling therapy
ncpg
igaming ontario
If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, crisis counseling and referral services can be accessed by calling 1-800-GAMBLER (1-800-426-2537) (IL). Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER (MI/NJ/OH/PA/WV), 1-800-9-WITH-IT (IN), 1-800-522-4700 (CO), 1-800-BETS OFF (IA), 1-888-532-3500 (VA) or call/text TN REDLINE 1-800-889-9789 (TN).
19+. Please play responsibly. Terms and conditions apply. 
Individuals must be 19 years of age or older to participate in igaming in Ontario. Gambling can be addictive, please play responsibly. If you, or someone you know, has a gambling problem in Ontario and wants help, please visit ConnexOntario or call their helpline at 1-866-531-2600. Operators on this website operate pursuant to an Operating Agreement with iGaming Ontario.

Search Sports Handle

No Result
View All Result
  • About Us / Contact
  • Responsible Gambling

No Result
View All Result
  • US Sports Betting
    • Arizona
    • Arkansas
    • Colorado
    • Connecticut
    • Delaware
    • Illinois
    • Indiana
    • Iowa
    • Kansas
    • Louisiana
    • Maine
    • Maryland
    • Massachusetts
    • Michigan
    • Mississippi
    • New Jersey
    • New Mexico
    • New York
    • Ohio
    • Oregon
    • Pennsylvania
    • Tennessee
    • Virginia
    • West Virginia
    • Wyoming
  • Pending States
    • California
    • Florida
    • Georgia
    • Missouri
    • North Carolina
  • Canada
    • Ontario
    • British Columbia
    • Alberta
  • Sportsbook Apps
    • FanDuel
    • BetMGM
    • Caesars
    • PointsBet
    • BetRivers
  • Tools
    • Sportsbook Bonuses Explained
    • Sports Betting Revenue Tracker
    • Sports Betting Podcasts
    • Partnership Tracker
    • Expected Value
    • Sports Scores And Odds Apps
    • Sports Betting Twitter
    • Guide To ‘Risk-Free’ Bets
  • News

loading

Please wait while you are redirected to the right page...

Please share your location to continue.

Check our help guide for more info.

share your location