• About Us / Contact
  • Responsible Gambling
This site contains commercial content
SportsHandle
  • US Sports Betting
    • Arizona
    • Arkansas
    • Colorado
    • Connecticut
    • Delaware
    • Illinois
    • Indiana
    • Iowa
    • Kansas
    • Kentucky
    • Louisiana
    • Maine
    • Maryland
    • Massachusetts
    • Michigan
    • Mississippi
    • New Jersey
    • New Mexico
    • New York
    • Ohio
    • Oregon
    • Pennsylvania
    • Tennessee
    • Vermont
    • Virginia
    • West Virginia
    • Wyoming
  • Pending States
    • California
    • Florida
    • Georgia
    • Missouri
    • North Carolina
  • Canada
    • Ontario
    • British Columbia
    • Alberta
  • Sportsbook Apps
    • FanDuel
    • BetMGM
    • Caesars
    • PointsBet
    • BetRivers
  • Tools
    • Sportsbook Bonuses Explained
    • Sports Betting Revenue Tracker
    • Sports Betting Podcasts
    • Partnership Tracker
    • Expected Value
    • Sports Scores And Odds Apps
    • Sports Betting Twitter
  • News
No Result
View All Result
SportsHandle
  • US Sports Betting
    • Arizona
    • Arkansas
    • Colorado
    • Connecticut
    • Delaware
    • Illinois
    • Indiana
    • Iowa
    • Kansas
    • Kentucky
    • Louisiana
    • Maine
    • Maryland
    • Massachusetts
    • Michigan
    • Mississippi
    • New Jersey
    • New Mexico
    • New York
    • Ohio
    • Oregon
    • Pennsylvania
    • Tennessee
    • Vermont
    • Virginia
    • West Virginia
    • Wyoming
  • Pending States
    • California
    • Florida
    • Georgia
    • Missouri
    • North Carolina
  • Canada
    • Ontario
    • British Columbia
    • Alberta
  • Sportsbook Apps
    • FanDuel
    • BetMGM
    • Caesars
    • PointsBet
    • BetRivers
  • Tools
    • Sportsbook Bonuses Explained
    • Sports Betting Revenue Tracker
    • Sports Betting Podcasts
    • Partnership Tracker
    • Expected Value
    • Sports Scores And Odds Apps
    • Sports Betting Twitter
  • News
No Result
View All Result
SportsHandle
No Result
View All Result

Judge Calls For Halt Of Florida Sports Betting After Ruling For Parimutuels

Federal judge calls compact illegal and puts stop to wagering in biggest legal U.S. state

Jill R. Dorson by Jill R. Dorson
November 23, 2021
in Regulation
Gavel-Word-Overturn

Shutterstock

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

A federal judge in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia ruled in favor of two parimutuels late Monday, shutting down legal sports betting in Florida. The decision is a major blow to the Seminole Tribe, which earlier this year agreed to a controversial compact with the state for a monopoly on sports betting. The tribe went live with digital wagering via its Hard Rock platform on Nov. 1, but had not yet launched in-person betting.

The decision means that sports betting authorized by the new Seminoles’ compact is no longer permissible in Florida, though it’s likely that the Seminoles will immediately appeal and ask for a stay on the decision. An appeal would send the case to a federal appeals court. At that level, a three-judge panel will hear arguments, but experts say that process often takes six months or more.

“On the merits, it is well-settled that IGRA authorizes sports betting only on Indian lands,” Judge Dabney Friedrich wrote. “This requirement stems from IGRA § 2710(d)(8)(A), which authorizes the Secretary to approve compacts ‘governing gaming on Indian lands.’ 25 U.S.C. § 2710(d)(8)(A). It is repeated in IGRA § 2710(d)(1), which lists the conditions under which ‘[c]lass III gaming activities shall be lawful on Indian lands.’ Id. § 2710(d)(1). Altogether, over a dozen provisions in IGRA regulate gaming on ‘Indian lands,’ and none regulate gaming in another location. Indeed, if there were any doubt on the issue, the Supreme Court has emphasized that ‘[e]verything—literally everything—in IGRA affords tools … to regulate gaming on Indian lands, and nowhere else.’ Bay Mills, 572 U.S. at 795.”

Because the judge vacated the entire compact, the Seminoles also will not be able to move forward with an expansion of retail gaming that was set to add craps and roulette to the tribe’s retail offerings. Under the new compact, the tribe was set to pay the state $2.5 billion over five years, but that money may be lost — at least for now — as the judge ordered the state and tribe to revert to the 2010 compact.

Seminoles’ motion to intervene denied

In finding for the plaintiffs, Friedrich granted their request for summary judgment and denied the Seminole Tribe’s motion to intervene in the case. And contrary to a finding by a federal judge in the North Florida District who dismissed a similar case saying the same plaintiffs did not have standing, Friedrich found that the plaintiffs did prove they had “standing” in the case and would be “injured” by the state’s decision to allow digital wagering by the Seminoles only.

Welp so much for sports betting in Florida. Hope everyone cashed out. https://t.co/CdUMVoLOew

— Allan Bell (@AllanBell247) November 23, 2021

The compact has been the subject of discussion across the country since the tribe and Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis agreed that if digital wagers flowed through a server on tribal lands, the bets would be deemed to be placed on those lands. That language appeared all along to be a potential violation of the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, which outlines what wagering on Indian lands can look like but does not offer any guidance off of reservations. At the time the compact was approved by the state legislature in May, lawmakers believed lawsuits were coming.

Sign Up For The Sports Handle Newsletter!
I also want to receive information and offers about online sportsbooks (eg. odds boost, welcome offers)

“It doesn’t take a master’s degree to know that there will be litigation,” said Rep. Sam Garrison when lawmakers approved the compact, which was then sent to the U.S. Department of the Interior for approval. Secretary Deb Haaland allowed the compact to become “deemed approved,” meaning she did approve it, but took no action during a 45-day review window.

‘Court cannot accept that fiction’

On Nov. 5, Friedrich heard arguments from West Flagler Associations and the Bonita-Fort Meyers Association, as well as the Department of Justice on behalf of Haaland. At that time, the DOJ was unprepared to argue the case, and Friedrich chastised lawyers but gave them four more days to file a written argument, the merits of which she clearly did not accept.

midnight snack, East Coast time – have my analysis on the federal judge nuking FLA sports betting tonight: https://t.co/jfyygnZieL then you can go right to sleep #SportsBiz

— John Brennan (@BergenBrennan) November 23, 2021

“The instant Compact attempts to authorize sports betting both on and off Indian lands. In its own words, the Compact authorizes such betting by patrons who are ‘physically located in the State [of Florida] but not on [the Tribe’s] Indian Lands.’ Compact § III(CC)(2) (emphasis added). That italicized phrase is no slip of the tongue, but instead describes the basic consequence of authorizing online betting throughout the State,” Friedrich wrote. “And although the Compact ‘deem[s]’ all sports betting to occur at the location of the Tribe’s ‘sports book(s)’ and supporting servers, see Compact § III(CC)(2), this Court cannot accept that fiction. When a federal statute authorizes an activity only at specific locations, parties may not evade that limitation by ‘deeming’ their activity to occur where it, as a factual matter, does not.”

Friedrich essentially said Haaland never should have allowed the compact because it clearly violates the IGRA.

Surprising result?

Many in the legal community believed Friedrich would follow her North Florida District counterpart and dismiss the case based on standing. In fact, two law professors told Sports Handle earlier this month that the case had little chance of success, with one calling it “dead on arrival.”

The decision is a blockbuster, but it’s not the end of the line for the Seminoles or for legal wagering in Florida, where any expansion of gaming is legally supposed to go to the voters since Amendment 3 was passed in 2018. Friedrich noted that sports betting could be legalized in the state either through a new compact or via a “citizens’ initiative.”

A political committee funded by DraftKings and FanDuel is currently gathering signatures for just such an initiative, which would allow for statewide digital wagering both on and off Indian lands. The committee has until early next year to collect the 891,589 signatures needed to get on the ballot. As of Monday night, 116,123 signatures had been verified, and according to the committee, it had collected more than 500,000 signatures and is “confident” will be able to collect the total needed by Feb. 1, 2022.

ShareTweetShare
Jill R. Dorson

Jill R. Dorson

Jill has covered everything from steeplechase to the NFL and then some during a more than 30-year career in sports journalism. The highlight of her career was covering Oakland Raiders during the Charles Woodson/Jon Gruden era, including the infamous “Snow Bowl” and the Raiders’ 2003 trip to Super Bowl XXXVII. Her specialty these days is covering sports betting legislation across the country. You can reach Jill at [email protected]

Related Posts

maginfier-over-small-print
Analysis

Read The Fine Print: A Proposed Federal Rule Could Change Everything For Indian Gaming

March 6, 2023
Bob Self/Florida Times-Union/USA TODAY
Sports

Florida’s NFL Teams Make Rare Joint Playoff Appearance, All As Underdogs

January 11, 2023
Load More

Top Stories

colts logo

Source: ‘Pervasive’ Wagering From Colts Player Includes Bets On His Own Team

June 5, 2023
paspa ruling

From PASPA To Present: An Oral History Of The U.S. Sports Betting Gold Rush

May 11, 2023
inside-fanatics-sportsbook-fedex-field

Sources: Fanatics Enters Advanced Talks With PointsBet On Transformative U.S. Deal

May 12, 2023
new york times headquarters

The ‘Risky Wager’ Series From New York Times Was No Hit Piece — It’s Reality

May 31, 2023

State Sports Betting Guides

Ohio (U.S. state) flag waving against clear blue sky, close up, isolated with clipping path mask alpha channel transparency, perfect for film, news, composition

Ohio Sports Betting – All Online Sportsbooks, Bonus Offers, and News 2023

by Brian Pempus
May 16, 2023

Downtown Detroit at twilight (Shutterstock)

Michigan Sports Betting – Where To Play, Online Sportsbooks, And FAQ

by Brett Smiley
May 2, 2023

VA captial

Virginia Sports Betting – Where To Play, Online Sportsbooks And Bonus Offers

by Brett Smiley
April 24, 2023

nj flag

New Jersey Sports Betting — Where To Play, Online Sportsbooks, And FAQ

by Brett Smiley
March 22, 2023

pa online sportsbooks

Pennsylvania Sports Betting – Where To Play, Online Sportsbooks And Bonuses

by Brett Smiley
May 3, 2023

Canada Sports Betting Guides

Canada Sports Betting – Best Sportsbook Apps & Bonus Offers

British Columbia Sports Betting – Legal Update, Available Sportsbooks, and FAQ

Ontario Sports Betting – Legal Status And Where To Play

SportsHandle

  • Analysis
  • Casino
  • Features
  • Horse Racing
  • Industry
  • Legal
  • Legislation
  • Lottery
  • Opinion
  • Podcasts
  • Poker
  • Politics
  • Promotions
  • Regulation
  • Sports
  • Uncategorized

Better Collective

This website is owned and operated by Better Collective USA. Trademarks and copyrights referenced on this website are and shall remain the exclusive property of their respective owners and/or licensors. Please be sure to visit the operator’s website(s) to review their terms & conditions. We advise you to read these carefully as they contain important information. Copyright © 2023 USBets.com | Better Collective USA
21 Play Responsibly
Gamble Aware West Virginia
Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-Gambler.
GameSense

Search Sports Handle

No Result
View All Result
  • About Us / Contact
  • Responsible Gambling

No Result
View All Result
  • US Sports Betting
    • Arizona
    • Arkansas
    • Colorado
    • Connecticut
    • Delaware
    • Illinois
    • Indiana
    • Iowa
    • Kansas
    • Kentucky
    • Louisiana
    • Maine
    • Maryland
    • Massachusetts
    • Michigan
    • Mississippi
    • New Jersey
    • New Mexico
    • New York
    • Ohio
    • Oregon
    • Pennsylvania
    • Tennessee
    • Vermont
    • Virginia
    • West Virginia
    • Wyoming
  • Pending States
    • California
    • Florida
    • Georgia
    • Missouri
    • North Carolina
  • Canada
    • Ontario
    • British Columbia
    • Alberta
  • Sportsbook Apps
    • FanDuel
    • BetMGM
    • Caesars
    • PointsBet
    • BetRivers
  • Tools
    • Sportsbook Bonuses Explained
    • Sports Betting Revenue Tracker
    • Sports Betting Podcasts
    • Partnership Tracker
    • Expected Value
    • Sports Scores And Odds Apps
    • Sports Betting Twitter
  • News